Is ESG Signalling Civilisational Decline? With Jeet Sidhu
Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio
Download Episode MP3 File
The file will open in a new window. Click down arrow to download the file.
In this interview, I talk to Jeet Sidhu and we discuss whether the promotion of obviously deficient ESG standards is a signal of a wider societal malaise: decivilisation, overregulation, political incompetence and consistent policy failures. Is human flourishing on the ropes?
- - - -
Environmental, social, and corporate governance (ESG) is a framework that was established by the UN in coordination with financial institutions in 2004. It was an attempt to expand the boundaries of the Friedman doctrine, which limits the social responsibility of businesses to increasing shareholder value. ESG essentially seeks to introduce altruistic goals for businesses.
The business community's reaction has been both rational and ironic: it has sought to use and capture ESG to maximise profits for shareholders. According to Bloomberg, ESG is the fastest growing asset management class, which is expected to exceed $50 trillion in value this year. Yet, according to EY, ESG is confusing, opaque, and subject to rampant greenwashing.
Is this exploitation of a worthy initiative an isolated anomaly that can be corrected? Or, is it evidence of a wider and more malevolent decline in society? The reality is that this isn’t the only major fault within our systems. Everyone is aware of the soft corruption of competence and the hard corruption of honesty. These have cascaded and infected our institutions.
We now live in a world that has exploited and tainted progressive language: selfish designs are hidden behind worthy declarations. We have rejected hard truths in return for expedient fiction. To what end? Are we more resilient? Do we have more efficient systems? Is society fairer? Seemingly not. This seems like an existential decline. Now is the time for honest new ideas.
00:03:43: Introductions
00:05:31: Jeet's background and view on climate change
00:11:39: The arrow of influence, and incentives driving the ESG movement
00:16:11: Overregulation, decivilisation and loss of knowledge
00:27:35: The right balance of regulation
00:42:00: The absence of competence in decision-makers
00:51:48: Selectorate theory, and using moral language to push self-interests
00:58:51: BlackRock and the origins of ESG
01:05:14: Commercial elites vs political elites
01:09:46: Where ESG has gone wrong
01:16:01: Energy transition and grid reliability, and the nuclear argument
01:22:27: Russian sanctions and energy in Europe
01:26:24: Failure of social policy interventions
01:29:45: Externalities of energy production
01:40:07: The unpopular solution is often the correct one
01:49:57: Unrealistic timescales for transition to zero carbon emissions
01:51:55: Social risk in deviating from popular opinion
01:53:54: The university system
01:59:02: Final comments
SUPPORT THE SHOW
If you enjoy The What Bitcoin Did Podcast you can help support the show by doing the following:
Become a Patron and get access to shows early or help contribute
Make a tip:
Subscribe on iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | SoundCloud | YouTube | TuneIn | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the show and episodes with your friends and family
Subscribe to the newsletter on my website
Follow me on Twitter Personal | Twitter Podcast | Instagram | Medium | YouTube
If you are interested in sponsoring the show, you can read more about that here or please feel free to drop me an email to discuss options.
SPONSORS
Connect with Jeet:
On Twitter
Mentioned in the interview:
'Dean of Valuation' Aswath Damodaran sees no good points in ESG - Seeking Alpha, Sep 2021
Why Tesla CEO Elon Musk Is Calling ESG a 'Scam' - Time, May 25th 2022
Local man sidesteps city’s wishes, builds his own staircase at Etobicoke park - CTV News, Jul 2019
Why does it cost so much to build things in America? - Vox, Jun 2021
What's Behind America's Shocking Baby-Formula Shortage? - The Atlantic, May 12th 2022
Denser cities could be a climate boon – but nimbyism stands in the way - The Guardian, Aug 2021
Opinion | What America Needs Is a Liberalism That Builds - NY Times, May 2022
The Afghanistan Papers - A Secret History Of The War, Washington Post, Dec 2019
“Bagram is the ivermectin of Afghanistan policy” - @paulkrugman, Aug 27th 2021
Larry Fink Defends His Embrace of E.S.G. - The New York Times, Jan 18th 2022
Money, blockchains, and social scalability - Nick Szabo, Feb 2017
Is Tucker Carlson right to blame ESG for Sri Lanka’s crisis? - FT, Jul 15 2022
Devin Nunes claims Russia is financing environmentalism - E&E News (eenews.net)
List of nuclear and radiation accidents by death toll - Wikipedia
Iceland boss: UK has more food banks than McDonalds - BBC, Sep 2021
The Fifth Risk: Undoing Democracy Paperback by Michael Lewis
Chart: Wind Turbines Are Not Killing Fields for Birds | Statista
What German households pay for power - Clean Energy Wire, Dec 2021
Number of healthcare administrators explodes since 1970 | athenahealth
Other Relevant WBD Podcasts:
WBD523: The Moral Case for Renewable Energy with Andrew Dessler
WBD493: Is There a Moral Case for Fossil Fuels? with Alex Epstein
WBD481: Bitcoin’s Clean Energy Revolution with Nic Carter & Troy Cross
WBD398: ESG & Institutional Bitcoin Investment with Kevin O’Leary
Defiance 029: The Real Science Of Climate Change | Prof. Katharine Hayhoe
Defiance 024: The Origins Of Climate Denialism | Nathaniel Rich