Fighting the Bitcoin Mining FUD with Troy Cross
Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio
Download Episode MP3 File
The file will open in a new window. Click down arrow to download the file.
Troy Cross is a Professor of Philosopher and Fellow at the Bitcoin Policy Institute. In this interview, we discuss the changing narrative around Bitcoin mining: is it finding its real utility in a bear market as the ultimate auxiliary tool, and how early are we in discovering its range of uses as a tool?
- - - -
The trajectory of Bitcoin mining’s narrative has been breathtaking. Over the last year, it has gone from being singularly promoted for its principal role in securing the Bitcoin network, to having a whole host of other uses identified and championed: subsidising stranded energy, stabilising energy grids, mitigating methane emissions, and providing heat for a range of activities.
Policymakers are struggling to keep up. The tired old FUD of Bitcoin’s energy use and carbon footprint are still being used as attack vectors by supposed reputable institutions such as the ECB. It also feeds into the narratives picked up by policymakers such as the White House, who’s commissioned report on Bitcoin mining’s climate impacts was affected by mainstream ignorance.
But, the White House report also included recognition of some of Bitcoin mining’s emerging benefits, as well as correcting some misrepresentations of its impacts. This shows that, whilst we are far from getting widespread acceptance of the importance of Bitcoin mining, the effort spent on education and advocacy by the Bitcoin community is having a vital real-world impact.
Promoting Bitcoin mining’s evolving narrative is critical. This is because we’re on the cusp of some far-reaching regulation in the wake of recent crypto scams. Regulators could see this as an opportunity to constrain Bitcoin mining; politicians never let a good crisis go to waste.
Yet, we are still early in understanding the scope of Bitcoin mining’s value. New uses are being researched and developed all the time: OTEC, water desalination and carbon capture are recent examples. Bitcoin mining is emerging as perhaps an engineer's ultimate auxiliary tool. The mission is therefore to not only continue to convey Bitcoin mining’s importance, but provide the widest possible frame for its significance.
00:02:08: Introductions
00:09:26: Philosophy, Plato and democracy
00:16:33: The Bitcoin philosophy subculture
00:24:41: Blind spots, learning, and ignorance
00:32:24: Diversity in Bitcoin
00:45:26: Political polarisation
00:51:08: Bitcoin is breaking down political incentives
00:57:02: Bitcoin mining's "perfect storm", and its subsequent evolution
01:06:03: Net carbon negative Bitcoin mining
01:22:54: The impact of scams and fraud on Bitcoin
01:27:58: Systemic failure in crypto leading to regulation
01:40:13: Fraud, enforcements, and the problem of leverage
01:55:42: Framing the topic of Bitcoin, energy and the environment
02:02:42: Bitcoin is disrupting multiple industries
02:08:18: Water distillation and carbon capture with ASICs
02:21:03: Final comments
SUPPORT THE SHOW
If you enjoy The What Bitcoin Did Podcast you can help support the show by doing the following:
Become a Patron and get access to shows early or help contribute
Make a tip:
Subscribe on iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | SoundCloud | YouTube | TuneIn | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the show and episodes with your friends and family
Subscribe to the newsletter on my website
Follow me on Twitter Personal | Twitter Podcast | Instagram | Medium | YouTube
If you are interested in sponsoring the show, you can read more about that here or please feel free to drop me an email to discuss options.
SPONSORS
Connect with Troy:
Mentioned in the interview:
Bitcoin Miner Made Millions in Credits by Shutting Rigs During Texas Heat - Bloomberg, Aug 3rd 2022
Profiting On Biogas With Bitcoin Mining [Scilling Mining, Ireland] - Bitcoin Magazine, Oct 10th 2022
Repurposing Bitcoin mining heat can solve global energy crisis: Arcane - Cointelegraph, Sep 4th 2022
Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index (CBECI) - Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance
When Genius Failed: The Rise and Fall of Long Term Capital Management - Roger Lowenstein, Jan 2002
What Happens When Crypto Meets Ted Lasso - NY Times, Nov 6th 2022
Other Relevant WBD Podcasts:
WBD574: How Capital Misallocation Warps Money with Steven Lubka
WBD571: The White House is Wrong About Bitcoin Mining with Nic Carter
WBD563: Bitcoin, Unleashing an Ocean of Energy with Nathaniel Harmon
WBD562: How Bitcoin Helps Mitigate Climate Change with Harald Rauter
WBD557: Mining Bitcoin with Nuclear Energy with Ryan MacLeod
WBD551: Fedimint & the Future of Bitcoin Custody with Obi Nwosu
WBD536: How Crypto Replayed the 2008 Financial Crisis with David Morris
WBD493: Is There a Moral Case for Fossil Fuels? with Alex Epstein
WBD481: Bitcoin’s Clean Energy Revolution with Nic Carter & Troy Cross
WBD463: Can Bitcoin Mining Save the Environment? with Troy Cross
WBD423: Emancipation From Financial Patriarchy with Anita Posch
WBD266: How Bitcoin is Helping Protesters in Belarus with Alex Gladstein & Jaraslau Likhachevski
Defiance 029 - The Real Science Of Climate Change | Prof. Katharine Hayhoe