Collectivism v Individualism with Robert Breedlove
Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio
Download Episode MP3 File
The file will open in a new window. Click down arrow to download the file.
Robert Breedlove is a philosopher within the Bitcoin space. In this interview, we discuss useful fictions used for collective organisation, slavery as the violation of property rights, Bitcoin changing the logic of violence, and the reality of an anarcho-capitalist world.
- - - -
Cooperation across large groups is the basis for the rise and evolution of human civilisation. As the historian Yuval Noah Harari espouses, such cooperation has been enabled through the exploitation of useful fictions (i.e. religion, national identities) by elites throughout time. The rights of the individual were crushed under the weight of the demands and cohesiveness of the group.
A rebalancing of power between collectives and the individual occurred during the enlightenment. It began with the development of a theory of natural rights, where individuals were determined to deserve access to "life, liberty, and estate (property)". The French and American revolutions in the 18th Century were premised on this belief.
A modern theory of universal human rights has developed since WW2. And yet, many feel we still have a long way to go before we achieve true liberty for the individual. Even the most open democratic societies work under an implicit social contract, where certain rights are foregone in exchange for political order. Coercion and control are less explicit, but still apparent.
So, what is the extent of the libertarian ideal? Is it an anarcho (i.e. without a leader) capitalist state? Or, is a hierarchy of power a necessary evil to thwart the chaos of natural law, which Hobbes stated would result in human life being "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short"? The problem has been that states throughout history have tended to extend their control.
Maybe the question isn’t a binary choice between an inevitable creep of state control over anarchy, but a balance that aims to achieve the benefits of both approaches. In such a situation individuals would need the power to ‘dethrone’ the ruler(s) without resorting to violence. Does Bitcoin enable such a balance?
00:04:19: Introductions
00:04:53: Multiple definitions of society
00:10:08: Coercion and democracy
00:12:42: The terminology of, "Useful fiction"
00:17:50: Maths provides our grip on reality
00:21:28: Human action versus animal behaviour
00:25:24: Slavery as a violation of property rights
00:29:47: Boom and bust cycles
00:31:49: Defining anarchy
00:34:49: Is the US the greatest socioeconomic experiment?
00:43:49: Democracy has brought fairness
00:45:52: Bitcoin changes the logic of violence
00:51:14: The net impact to a Bitcoin society
00:56:40: The destructive nature of hyperinflation
00:58:18: Defining the term "fiat"
01:00:30: Reality of an imagined new Bitcoin world
01:10:26: The corrosiveness of groupthink
01:12:07: Negative and positive liberty
01:18:10: Final comments
SUPPORT THE SHOW
If you enjoy The What Bitcoin Did Podcast you can help support the show by doing the following:
Become a Patron and get access to shows early or help contribute
Make a tip:
Subscribe on iTunes | Spotify | Stitcher | SoundCloud | YouTube | TuneIn | RSS Feed
Leave a review on iTunes
Share the show and episodes with your friends and family
Subscribe to the newsletter on my website
Follow me on Twitter Personal | Twitter Podcast | Instagram | Medium | YouTube
If you are interested in sponsoring the show, you can read more about that here or please feel free to drop me an email to discuss options.
SPONSORS
Connect with Robert:
Mentioned in the interview:
Justin Trudeau ends Canada’s trucker siege but leaves bitter divisions - FT, Feb 20th 2022
The "Rights" of Animals - Mises Institute, Murray N. Rothbard, Jul 2007
Inside the Modern Slave Trade Trapping African Migrants - Time, Mar 2019
The Discovery of Freedom: Man's Struggle Against Authority - Rose Wilder Lane
When Money Dies: The Nightmare of the Weimar Hyperinflation - Adam Fergusson
Other Relevant WBD Podcasts:
WBD459: Bitcoin & The Canadian Truckers with Greg Foss & NobodyCaribou
WBD438: Separation of Money & State with Matt Stoller & Peter Van Valkenburgh
WBD434: Bitcoin & The Battle For The Fate Of Humanity with Mark Moss
WBD352: The Sovereign Individual Pt 2 - The Logic of Violence with Robert Breedlove
WBD320: The Sovereign Individual Pt 1 - Bitcoin: The Ultimate Offshore Bank with Robert Breedlove
WBD311: Bitcoin & The Sovereign Company with Christian Keroles & Robert Breedlove
WBD265: What is Bitcoin? With Parker Lewis, Robert Breedlove & Vijay Boyapati
WBD220: Bitcoin is Reshaping the World with Robert Breedlove